Subject: Fw: Corruption: Brazen, Blatant & Bare-faced!
Date: Sun, 23 Oct 2011 22:06:49 +0100
A good letter Norman and an excellent exposition of Maurice’s perilous, inhuman and unlawful incarceration…
—– Original Message —–

Sent: Sunday, October 23, 2011 5:32 PM
Subject: Corruption: Brazen, Blatant & Bare-faced!

To Lord Goodhart,

Sir, We note from Hansard your statement & question in the House of Lords on 6th September 2011, in which you said,

“My Lords, Transparency International UK, of which I am a member, published in June this year a document called ‘Corruption in the United Kingdom’.  It concluded that corruption is a greater problem than has been recognised and is being recognised by governments.  Have the present government considered that document and have they got the Serious Fraud Office adequately into the picture?”

–       – – – – — – – – – – – – – – – – – —

We suggest that no corruption is more BRAZEN, BLATANT & BAREFACED than that described below.

Barbara Wilding was Chief Constable of South Wales Police.  She was (& may still be) Chairwoman of a Big Lottery Fund which hands out large sums of money to Mental Hospitals in South Wales.

Maurice Kirk (‘The Flying Vet’) has many court actions (civil & criminal) against South Wales Police, & there is obviously no love lost between them.

A keen amateur pilot, he bought a replica World War I biplane which had attached to it a piece of ornamental ironmongery which had once been a Lewis Gun, but was no longer capable of being used as such.  Kirk was prosecuted for ‘Dealing in Firearms Without a Licence’. though neither the previous nor subsequent owners were prosecuted.  Kirk was remanded in custody in HM Prison Cardiff, but certain people were anxious the ridiculous charge would never come to trial.

–       – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – –

DR. X is a psychiatrist who runs Caswell Clinic ‘Mental Hospital’ in Bridgend.

So, ‘Dr’ X  was persuaded to give a completely false diagnosis (mental illness, brain tumour etc.) to take Kirk into his clinic, following which he recommended that Kirk should be transferred to a High Security Mental Hospital such as Ashworth or Broadmoor.

That meant there would be no need for SW Police or the CPS to prove his guilt, but this man who was such a nuisance to them would be locked away, silenced for ever!

We quote Nobel Laureate Alekzandr Solzhenitsyn, “To put a sane person in a madhouse (his word) is worse than the gas chambers: the torture is more cruel, death takes longer”.

X proved himself not only a sadist, but extremely stupid: he put in writing as reasons for holding Kirk captive, “If released he would probably take action through the courts against SW Police”.

The General Medical Council were told of this, but, astonishingly, could see nothing wrong with it – even when reminded of how they had covered up for Harold Shipman, thus allowing him to kill many more after he should have been stopped

Fortunately, Kirk escaped the fate Dr. X had in store for him & was returned to HM Prison Cardiff.  The trial DID eventually take place, & he was acquitted by a jury who knew the difference between right & wrong.

One might think that with so much egg on the faces of the police, the CPS & Dr. Williams they would cease their persecution of Kirk.


This 66 year old man is AGAIN in HMP Cardiff on remand, this time having been charged with ‘harassing’ Dr. X  (or something similar).   The truth is that he has been trying very hard to get a copy of his medical records from X who (perhaps not surprisingly) is determined Kirk will not even get sight of them!

Lord Goodhart:

We note that apart from being a Commissioner of the International Court of Justice, you also hold other important positions within that field, viz. the International Commission of Jurists, ‘Justice’, the Parliamentary Committee on Standards in Public Life, et al.

We trust that you will do something about the diabolical situation described above, using such influence as you have to ensure that Maurice Kirk gets bail (at the very LEAST), & that the Serious Fraud Office show they are more than puppets.  Hopefully it will help to improve the low opinion held by many abroad of the standards of ‘Justice’ & ‘Human Rights’ in Britain.

Norman Scarth.

World War II Veteran.  Associate of the Article 6 Group.


Chronology of Collusion – or Dare we Call it Conspiracy?
This chronology was written by Maurice J Kirk BVSc.

Remember he was struck off the Register of Veterinary
Surgeons and known as the ‘flying vet’, as he was also a famous pilot. South Wales Police colluded with lawyers to
get him struck off with their 40 odd ‘incidents of harassment’ for which Maurice is trying to claim damages since 20
years. But in the process of trying to get fair trails and compensation, he’s encountered what other victims of white
collar crimes have experienced:
any variation of “fraud”: a crime and a civil law violation,
the non-investigation of crimes by Police,
corruption among solicitors, judges and court staff,
the absence of fair trials (Article 6) and an effective remedy before national authorities (Article 13) according
to the European Convention on Human Rights
and generally, in mild terms, dishonesty and white collar crimes.
Maurice wrote the chronology below whilst in Cardiff Prison since 23rd September 2011 – without any written
documentation for the reasons of his current imprisonment. His conditions are more than draconian: no medical
attention, limits to stamps, paper, pen, envelopes, no law books and above all, lies about him refusing to attend
court, when, in fact, he hasn’t been told about hearings.

Only on 13th October was he before a Magistrates Court where I witnessed four allegations before the Court. That
day only one was dealt with: the harassment of Dr X, the forensic psychiatrist responsible for
labelling him with “paranoid delusional disorder”, “significant brain damage” and “possible brain tumour”. Maurice
was not granted bail. When I visited him in prison six days later (that was the waiting time imposed on us!), he said
that he knew he wouldn’t get bail. For he is a ‘political’ prisoner. His case for damages must not get before the
courts, because South Wales Police are made to look not just guilty of bullying and harassment, but also like fools.
For the way that they treated the replica of a machine gun, attached to an historic aeroplane, was distinctly over the
top: armed police officers with helicopter, imprisonment for nearly eight months, three of which in a psychiatric
clinic, MAPPA (Multi-Agency Public Protection Arrangement) registration, as if he was a terrorist or sex offender.
Leaked documents revealed that South Wales Police had a ‘shoot to kill’ policy.

Of course, your personal experiences that formed your outlook on life in general and justice in particular will
determine how you respond to this account. From my perspective as web publisher and McKenzie Friend of many
victims of white collar crimes, this is distinctly the worst in terms of police harassment and yet it confirms what many
others have experienced:

The lack of integrity that lawyers and judges have demonstrated, thus causing victims to represent
o Maurice has failed to find legal representation for the adversarial system that lawyers rely upon for
their livelihood can’t possibly be questioned
The serious disadvantage that Litigants in Person experience
o Instead of victims getting fair trials and access to justice, solicitors are expected to make money from
representing them – independent of the outcome for victims
The desperate need for any organisation to ‘save face’ rather than admit to any mistake – whether it’s
Haringey Council regarding the stealing of six Nigerian children or South Wales Police regarding the ‘machine
gun’ as ‘possessing and trading with firearms’:
o In 2009, ten Cardiff judges “believed” the statements by Dr X that Maurice was “too
dangerous to be released”
o In 2011, his bail application was apparently heard, but Maurice wasn’t told in prison and couldn’t be
there, could he…
1993 Crown Court ignored Witness Affidavit recording police at Magistrates Court saying “We will get the bastard
talking human rights.”
1993 Magistrates sent me to prison until Police identified me.
1997 Crown Court ignored the CPS Barrister who summed up in his letter to the RCVS (Royal College of Veterinary
Surgeons) of CPS/ Police / HM Court Service (Wales) conspiracy to alter or withhold documents
1998 Crown Court ignored Jury complaining of senior police officer signalling to each of his mates during their
cross examination
1999 CPS ignored proven Police conspiracy, on oath, to frame me under the Terrorism Act, of flying my aircraft to
Southern Ireland
2001 Current trial judge, in my damages claim, acting then as Crown Court judge, ignored my GP and surgeon’s
medical reports that I was unable to attend court, dismissing my motoring appeal and later, in 2010, dismissing it as
part of my civil claim
2001 Magistrates had to dismiss all charges, but ignore the fact that all four Police motoring allegations were
2003 County Court manager’s clandestine activities refuse my barrister sight of court files, sending and losing
some of my 130 files to HM Solicitor General’s Office in Whitehall, attempting to have me registered as vexatious
litigant. County Court staff later leak internal memos as proof that the investigation continued for at least 5 years.
2004 County Court appeal, heard in Swansea, refused me a Jury Trial for damages claim. I’m refused a Jury for any
combination of the 35 police incidents in the first three of my eight civil actions for damages. Appeal was heard by
an earlier judge in 1987, in the civil proceedings, just to keep it in the family.
2005 County Court refuses to order Police disclosure of relevant incident numbers (I’d lost them) of around 100
Police Officers on their PNC (Police National Computer).
2008 County Court refuses me access to Court building, unless in Court hearing. County Court allows Police to
continue withholding identity of now 150 Police Officers in some 70 incidents, all subject to litigation for damages.
2009 Magistrates refuse ‘due process’ of my private prosecution, following Chief Constable’s false sworn Affidavit
stating she was ‘unaware’ of Police break-in to my veterinary surgery, identification of Police at 35 recorded
incidents and Magistrates hearings, all supporting the evidence of a conspiracy to pervert the Course of Justice
2009 Crown Court, HM Court Service and CPS all withhold prior knowledge of MAPPA conspiracy, weeks before
my June arrest for being in possession of a machine gun that Police were aware their conduct was likely to get me
shot. This was later confirmed by MAPPA minutes leaked from Caswell Clinic, Psychiatric Prison, Bridgend.
2009 60th law firm refused to represent me, while Crown Court judges tried to get me to employ their laundered
variety of independent legal representation
2009 Nine Crown Court judges knew or should have known, when refusing bail, that the Police forensic history
was false and had employed a rogue Dr X to falsify a psychiatric report without patient examination
and later stating I had ‘significant brain damage’ and possibly brain tumour with neither qualification or evidence.
2009/10 Successive Crown Court judges deliberately ignored my applications for proper disclosure which
would have shown Police painted the ‘machine gun’ a different colour to fool the Jury, leaving me to cause the Jury
to ask “Just how many machine guns feature in this case?”
2009 During my custody, my trial judge for civil action hands down a £50,000 compensation judgement on my
2008 false imprisonment only for it to be overturned in a lower Court, by a District Judge. He accepted, if you wish to
believe it, that the same HM Court Manager as in 2003, ‘forgot’ to serve the Particulars of Claim despite Police, the
2nd Defendant, admitting receiving it, with prisoner not allowed to produce any affidavit or record from the then
Governor, in rebuttal.
2010 Crown Court refused to order NHS / Caswell Clinic / South Wales Police to disclose my full medical records
during my custody. I am sent to prison for arguing. This leads to nine months of litigation delay, due to ill health and
refused medical County Court trial judge refuses to prosecute Police lawyers who, despite his previous order to
disclose, continue to this day to refuse to reveal their joint statement of complaint with the Chief Constable to have
me arrested by armed police unit with helicopter of that year.
2011 Both Crown and Magistrates Court block ongoing private prosecution first accepted in English Court with
both Welsh Courts ignoring my correspondence and now blocking my access to their public counter.
Sept. Magistrates oppose my bail accepting South Wales Police PNC printout falsely identifying under ‘Warning’:
firearms, weapons, violent, escaper, sex offender and long list including 08/09/11 “states concealed items in his
rectum in 2008 to effect escape.”
Oct. Both Crown & Magistrates accept HM Prison lying that I refuse to attend Court for bail applications. Both
Courts are aware I am refused proper medical attention for over 7 days in prison, have refused me letters, stamps /
canteen from private cash, access to telephone or appropriate staff to liaise with courts.
Oct 12th I will continue my hunger strike until I have return of my legal papers from Police, I obtain
appropriate medical attention, a writ of Habeas Corpus appropriately filed in the right Court, a successful Crown
Court appeal for bail, Welsh acceptance of filed private prosecutions and / or proper Police disclosure in my civil
actions to allow my lawyers to serve on Dr Tegwyn Williams appropriate Particulars of Claim for punitive damages
with Police as Co-Defendant.
In his commitment of helping and supporting other victims, Maurice made remarkable efforts of finding out where
the six stolen Nigerian children are. In the process he got himself arrested three times which, ultimately led to him
being transferred to HMP Cardiff.
His statements relating to these arrests are
1. Criminal Damage
2. Public Order Charge
3. Conspiracy to Abduct Children

About butlincat

my butlincats blog: [2 a/cs : pink cat logo is main a/c, winking cat logo is secondary] linkedin -
This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.